This is a follow up book to A Court of Thorns and Roses so obviously I had to pick it up and read it immediately. This book has some PG-13 to Rated-R moments....read at your own discretion.
Summary: Feyre survived Under the Mountain and battled her way to happily ever after. Except she's anything but happy. Feyre can't cope with the cost of her freedom, even though thousands were saved along with her. As Feyre sinks into a deep depression, her fiance Tamlin struggles with issues of his own. Determined to protect Feyre at any cost, he locks her in his manor house, isolating Feyre from the very things that give her hope. On the day of Feyre and Tamlin's wedding, Feyre realizes that she absolutely can't marry Tamlin. As her heart wishes for someone - anyone - to save her, the High Lord of the Night Court appears and whisks her away, claiming that it's time Feyre makes good on their bargain to spend time at the Night Court. Feyre's time in the Night Court helps her heal her soul, but also plunges her into the dangerous world of High Fae politics and the potential of a brutal and terrible war.
My Thoughts: I liked this sequel, even though it wasn't what I expected. Although longer than your usual YA novel, "A Court of Mist and Fury" was jam packed with plot, character development and action that made turning the pages quick and fun. And now to the meat...
First of all, how did I not notice that Tamlin was such a dirt ball in the first book? "A Court of Mist an Fury" paints Tamlin as a fairy equivalent of an abusive boyfriend. While Tamling never raises a hand to Feyre, he locks her in the house when she asks to go outside. This is not ok and is actually really scary, as at first Feyre seems to think its OK as Tamlin claims to be protecting her from the creatures on the lose in his realm. Further, Tamlin mentally abuses Feyre by convincing her not to take an active role in his life, or even in her own. He undermines her sense of self by convincing her that she's not as capable as she is. Maas tries to use the excuse that Tamlin was damaged by his experience Under the Hill (and I think that it right on) but it is done in such a secondary way that it seems like it comes out of nowhere. I felt this was sloppy on Maas' part, and an excuse to break the epic love story of Feyre and Tamlin a part. I think its fine for the characters to grow apart, I just wish there had been more of a buildup instead of a lot of the action taking place between books.
Secondly, I disliked Feyre much less in this book. I will even admit that, at times, I may have even liked her. While I found her depression and lack of will in the first few chapters frustrating, I thought it was well done and true to depression as I've seen it experienced. I also enjoyed Feyre's journey into self reliance and self discovery. Her time with the Night Court and the relationships explored there help her become if not a certified bad ass, well on the road to bad-assery. Don't get me wrong. Feyre is still petulant and cocky, but her heart grows to care for others in a way I wasn't sure was possible.
Lastly, I really enjoyed the setting and character development in "A Court of Mist and Fury". Maas has a masterful sense of description - I could see the lights of Velaris, see the beauty of the Night Court Palace and imagine every fabulous outfit worn by the main characters. The new supporting characters were interesting and integral part of Feyre's development. I wanted to learn more about them even as they skimmed in and out of each chapter.
Rating: Definitely read this, if you've read the first series. I'm going to re-read books #1 and #2 again as I feel if I missed a ton of setup in ACOTAR.
Reviewed By: Tami
Also Read By: A Court of Thorns and Roses (Book #1)
Showing posts with label young adult. Show all posts
Showing posts with label young adult. Show all posts
Tuesday, June 14, 2016
Tuesday, April 19, 2016
"Salt to the Sea" by Ruta Sepetys
![]() |
| Image via amazon |
Summary: The Red Army is advancing upon Germany, brutalizing anyone in their path. The Nazi's have ordered citizens to remain in place. Those who are caught disobeying orders are shipped off to work camps or killed. It's a brutally cold and lean winter. And you're a young adult on your own, hoping to make it to the coast and the ships that could bring you to safety...if the rumors are true. Told in alternating points of view, "Salt to the Sea" is the story of four young adults desperate to find safety in the unforgiving German countryside. As their paths cross, the young adults reluctantly band together, using each others strengths to and weaknesses to gain advantage and reach a ship that will take them out of harms way.
My Thoughts: "Salt to the Sea" is one of those books that I think about long after I've turned the last page. While I hold a degree in History, World War II has never been an event on which I've spent much time. Battles and politics don't interest me, and that's the gist of most lower education courses. What "Salt to the Sea" did differently, and what captured my attention so soundly, was the focus on the people effected by the war; specifically, those that would be left behind by those fighting: children, teens, the impaired and elderly.
To steal a term from the targeted demographic: this book gave me all the feels. At times I found "Salt to the Sea" so bone chilling I had to put the book down. The idea of children and young people left on their own in situations where death is near certain made me feel angry, helpless and unsettled. I wanted to know where the parents were, why the children were alone, and why someone didn't step in to protect them. However, when the story felt most bleak and all hope seemed dash, the bright glimmer of hope was woven through the fear and sadness. The combined goal of survival and sudden loyalty among the main characters lends a lighter touch to a dark story. I enjoyed watching the characters open their hearts to one another as they built their own family from the wreckage around them.
Overall, I thought "Salt to the Sea" was wonderfully written. The action was fast paced, which felt appropriate for the story and the events unfolding. The alternating view points of the four main characters flowed together masterfully - it was easy to keep track of the characters and their back stories and different view points added layers of emotion to the overall plot. Finally, although "Salt to the Sea" is a work of fiction, the authors passion for telling an honest story was well done. I imagine any of the plot points could--and probably did--happen.
Rating: I'll reread this one over and over again. Please note, there are some triggers in this book, as well as imagery some parents will not find acceptable for their children.
Also Read: Nothing yet, but the Author's other works are now on my TBR list.
Reviewed By: Tami
Tuesday, February 2, 2016
"A Court of Thorns and Roses" by Sarah Maas
Lately Instagram has been my go-to for finding new books to read. The Young Adult #bookstagram movement is as strong as it is fabulous.
Summary: Feyre lives in a small town with her depressed, emotionally dead father and two older, ungrateful and nasty sisters, in a shack that is all the family can afford since their fall from grace, money and power. In order to survive, Feyre does what she can to put food on her family's table. She hunts, she trades and she works twice as hard as she should to keep her family alive. During a hard winter with death looming over her shoulder, Feyre takes to the woods to find meat - any meat - for her family. She spies a deer in the forest and can't believe her luck...until she sees a larger-than-life wolf hunting the same prey. On instinct, Feyre shoots the wolf, killing him almost instantly while the deer gets away. Feyre soon learns that the wolf wasn't an ordinary wolf, that she in fact killed a member of the high Fey in disguise.
In order to keep peace between their two peoples, Feyre must trade her life for that of the Fey she murdered. But there's a twist. Instead of being put to death, Feyre must live in an enchanted castle at the Summer court of the Fey, surrounded by creatures she can't always see and magic she can feel but cannot touch. What at first seems like a land of plenty and prosperity soon begins to wither, as Feyre learns that even the Fey are not all powerful. An evil greater than she can understand threatens all she knows and all she's come to care for.
My Thoughts: I loved this book. The pacing was excellent, the story unique, characters vivid, and the plot as twisty and deep as an old river. What starts out as a Beauty and The Beast retelling soon turns into its own saga, complete with magic, forbidden love and a battle to the (literal) death.
I mostly liked Feyre...as much as I can like any teenager. Maas does a superb job capturing the iron will of someone who's had to grow up too soon and mixing it with the rash decisions and selfcentric world view of the young. Feyre is both strong-willed yet scared, cunning yet naive, compelling yet shallow. She is real in all her imperfections and I couldn't have asked for a better young adult heroine. (Note: I had no idea how to pronounce Feyre, so I called her Farrah the whole time.)
I also enjoyed the secondary characters. Tamlin is fascinating in his strong yet silent way. He suffers in a role he did not want yet works hard to succeed at anyway. He loves, but must hide it. And he comes off sexy in an alpha-male sort of way. Rhysand is the classic bad boy/dark lover character. He is both evil (like really evil) and alluring and I can't wait to see where book 2 takes his character. (But please not a love triangle. That is too expected and honestly, that would be disappointing.)
I did feel like the book was 100 pages too long. Don't get me wrong, it was good, but good lord did it take forever to read. If I was the editor, I would have cut the scene where Feyre goes home to her family. I understand that her family finally comes to appreciate her, and that this is (hopefully) set up for the sequel, but it was slow going for me. I also would have shortened the final challenge scenes, because this is where the book feels disjointed and rushed to me. I understand that Feyre needs to kick ass and prove her worth, but in the end it felt like the entire sequence was set up for Rhys instead of closure for Tamlin.
Rating: I'll read it again. Check it out if you like Young Adult or Fantasy.
Also Read By: N/A
Reviewed By: Tami
Summary: Feyre lives in a small town with her depressed, emotionally dead father and two older, ungrateful and nasty sisters, in a shack that is all the family can afford since their fall from grace, money and power. In order to survive, Feyre does what she can to put food on her family's table. She hunts, she trades and she works twice as hard as she should to keep her family alive. During a hard winter with death looming over her shoulder, Feyre takes to the woods to find meat - any meat - for her family. She spies a deer in the forest and can't believe her luck...until she sees a larger-than-life wolf hunting the same prey. On instinct, Feyre shoots the wolf, killing him almost instantly while the deer gets away. Feyre soon learns that the wolf wasn't an ordinary wolf, that she in fact killed a member of the high Fey in disguise.
In order to keep peace between their two peoples, Feyre must trade her life for that of the Fey she murdered. But there's a twist. Instead of being put to death, Feyre must live in an enchanted castle at the Summer court of the Fey, surrounded by creatures she can't always see and magic she can feel but cannot touch. What at first seems like a land of plenty and prosperity soon begins to wither, as Feyre learns that even the Fey are not all powerful. An evil greater than she can understand threatens all she knows and all she's come to care for.
My Thoughts: I loved this book. The pacing was excellent, the story unique, characters vivid, and the plot as twisty and deep as an old river. What starts out as a Beauty and The Beast retelling soon turns into its own saga, complete with magic, forbidden love and a battle to the (literal) death.
I mostly liked Feyre...as much as I can like any teenager. Maas does a superb job capturing the iron will of someone who's had to grow up too soon and mixing it with the rash decisions and selfcentric world view of the young. Feyre is both strong-willed yet scared, cunning yet naive, compelling yet shallow. She is real in all her imperfections and I couldn't have asked for a better young adult heroine. (Note: I had no idea how to pronounce Feyre, so I called her Farrah the whole time.)
I also enjoyed the secondary characters. Tamlin is fascinating in his strong yet silent way. He suffers in a role he did not want yet works hard to succeed at anyway. He loves, but must hide it. And he comes off sexy in an alpha-male sort of way. Rhysand is the classic bad boy/dark lover character. He is both evil (like really evil) and alluring and I can't wait to see where book 2 takes his character. (But please not a love triangle. That is too expected and honestly, that would be disappointing.)
I did feel like the book was 100 pages too long. Don't get me wrong, it was good, but good lord did it take forever to read. If I was the editor, I would have cut the scene where Feyre goes home to her family. I understand that her family finally comes to appreciate her, and that this is (hopefully) set up for the sequel, but it was slow going for me. I also would have shortened the final challenge scenes, because this is where the book feels disjointed and rushed to me. I understand that Feyre needs to kick ass and prove her worth, but in the end it felt like the entire sequence was set up for Rhys instead of closure for Tamlin.
Rating: I'll read it again. Check it out if you like Young Adult or Fantasy.
Also Read By: N/A
Reviewed By: Tami
Tuesday, January 26, 2016
"Beauty" by Robin McKinley
This story has been recommended to me countless times, but I've always put off picking it up. I stumbled across the book on instagram and finally gave it a try.
Summary: Beauty is a retelling of the classic Beauty and The Beast fairy tale. After losing their fortune to the winds of fate, Beauty and her family sell all they own and journey to the outskirts of civilization in order to make a new life. When her father's error of judgement brings a curse upon his family, Beauty, the youngest of three sisters, promises to spend the rest of her life with the Beast to save her father's life.
or
Disney read this book and made a movie from it.
My Thoughts: One thing I enjoy about all of McKinley's books is the vibrant and rich detail she gives her settings, characters and plots. While the true meat of Beauty is the story of how Beauty comes into her own at the enchanted castle, eventually leading up to her love for the Beast, the back story McKinley gives her cast is what truly captured my interest. I was captivated by Beauty and the gang's life on the edge of the enchanted forest as they learned how to survive outside of their lives as members of the privileged class. I believed Beauty's exhaustion as she used her muscles. I could appreciate Hope and Joy's goodness of heart as they learned to keep house and tend children. And I absolutely sympathized with their father as he unknowingly make a judgement of error that cost him his youngest child.
I also was pleasantly surprised that Beauty had a backbone. Beauty knew full well what she was getting into when she sacrificed her own life for her fathers. She took a known risk, trading her life as the youngest sister with few prospects but the love of a good family for a life of unknown but potential possibilities. Yes she makes a sacrifice for her family, but she doesn't pity herself (much) and makes her decision with self actualization and logic. Hurrah! A heroine I can be proud to share with the children in my family.
I really enjoyed this book, so much so that I can over look the cheesy happily-ever-after ending. I will also admit that I'm the type to find the beast more interesting as a beast instead of as a man. I thought McKinley did a phenomenal job on the Beast's back story as well as on his character development. He very well may have been my favorite character.
Rating: This is a fabulous story for readers of any age. Pick it up if you like fairy tales, Disney or incredibly well written young adult fantasy.
Reviewed By: Tami
Also Read By This Author: Chalice, The Hero and the Crown, The Blue Sword, Sunshine, Shadows
Summary: Beauty is a retelling of the classic Beauty and The Beast fairy tale. After losing their fortune to the winds of fate, Beauty and her family sell all they own and journey to the outskirts of civilization in order to make a new life. When her father's error of judgement brings a curse upon his family, Beauty, the youngest of three sisters, promises to spend the rest of her life with the Beast to save her father's life.
or
Disney read this book and made a movie from it.
My Thoughts: One thing I enjoy about all of McKinley's books is the vibrant and rich detail she gives her settings, characters and plots. While the true meat of Beauty is the story of how Beauty comes into her own at the enchanted castle, eventually leading up to her love for the Beast, the back story McKinley gives her cast is what truly captured my interest. I was captivated by Beauty and the gang's life on the edge of the enchanted forest as they learned how to survive outside of their lives as members of the privileged class. I believed Beauty's exhaustion as she used her muscles. I could appreciate Hope and Joy's goodness of heart as they learned to keep house and tend children. And I absolutely sympathized with their father as he unknowingly make a judgement of error that cost him his youngest child.
I also was pleasantly surprised that Beauty had a backbone. Beauty knew full well what she was getting into when she sacrificed her own life for her fathers. She took a known risk, trading her life as the youngest sister with few prospects but the love of a good family for a life of unknown but potential possibilities. Yes she makes a sacrifice for her family, but she doesn't pity herself (much) and makes her decision with self actualization and logic. Hurrah! A heroine I can be proud to share with the children in my family.
I really enjoyed this book, so much so that I can over look the cheesy happily-ever-after ending. I will also admit that I'm the type to find the beast more interesting as a beast instead of as a man. I thought McKinley did a phenomenal job on the Beast's back story as well as on his character development. He very well may have been my favorite character.
Rating: This is a fabulous story for readers of any age. Pick it up if you like fairy tales, Disney or incredibly well written young adult fantasy.
Reviewed By: Tami
Also Read By This Author: Chalice, The Hero and the Crown, The Blue Sword, Sunshine, Shadows
Tuesday, October 13, 2015
"Fangirl" by Rainbow Rowell
I saw mini reviews of "Fangirl" posted around Instagram. I liked the cover, and people seemed to really appreciate the story, so I picked it up from my local library!
Summary: Cath is your average 18 year old on the cusp of college...well, average if you're afraid of change, confused by normal social interactions and obsessed with a boy wizard. (So in my experience, average.)
"Fangirl" is about a girl who goes to college for the first time and finds herself totally out of her element. Cath starts off alone, intimidated by her new life and a little scared to take the next step into adulthood. She'd be just fine back at home, sharing her bedroom and her love of Simon Snow fanfiction with her twin sister, keeping track of her depressed dad, and eating from every taco truck in sight.
But college forces everyone to grow up, whether they're ready or not.
Cath soon finds herself making friends with her kinda-scary roommate, co-writing a story with a kinda-cute guy from her creative writing class, and learning about herself outside of her role as twin sister, daughter, and superstar fanfic writer. Oh, and she meets a man.
My Thoughts: Good books take the reader through a range of emotions as the story progresses. "Fangirl" was no different.
I started out uncomfortable, possibly because Cath hits a little too close to home. She's so anxious about starting college that she spends all her time in class or hiding out in her room. Going to the cafeteria in her dorm or talking to her roommate are too much for her. I can relate to this, as my own freshman (and sophomore....and junior) years were quite similar. Because of my personal experience, and because I know what it's like on the other side, I was uncomfortable and at times disappointed in Cath for letting her anxiety keep her from meeting people and experiencing new things.
As Cath branches out beyond her dorm room, I got more comfortable with the story and started to revel in Cath's quirkyness. Cath is unashamed of her obsession with the wildly popular Simon Snow series. She revels in total lack of desire to party with her sister. And she loves a good hipster sweater. While Cath has a penchant for crying that occasionally made me want to punch her in the face, her quick comebacks and good heart kept me cheering her on.
Then there is sadness. So much sadness.
And then there is the ending. But you'll have to read the book to find out if it's happy or not.
Rating: I recommend it, and I'll read it again.
Also Read By: None, but I'll check out more by Rainbow Rowell
Reviewed By: Tami
![]() |
| Image via Goodreads |
Summary: Cath is your average 18 year old on the cusp of college...well, average if you're afraid of change, confused by normal social interactions and obsessed with a boy wizard. (So in my experience, average.)
"Fangirl" is about a girl who goes to college for the first time and finds herself totally out of her element. Cath starts off alone, intimidated by her new life and a little scared to take the next step into adulthood. She'd be just fine back at home, sharing her bedroom and her love of Simon Snow fanfiction with her twin sister, keeping track of her depressed dad, and eating from every taco truck in sight.
But college forces everyone to grow up, whether they're ready or not.
Cath soon finds herself making friends with her kinda-scary roommate, co-writing a story with a kinda-cute guy from her creative writing class, and learning about herself outside of her role as twin sister, daughter, and superstar fanfic writer. Oh, and she meets a man.
My Thoughts: Good books take the reader through a range of emotions as the story progresses. "Fangirl" was no different.
I started out uncomfortable, possibly because Cath hits a little too close to home. She's so anxious about starting college that she spends all her time in class or hiding out in her room. Going to the cafeteria in her dorm or talking to her roommate are too much for her. I can relate to this, as my own freshman (and sophomore....and junior) years were quite similar. Because of my personal experience, and because I know what it's like on the other side, I was uncomfortable and at times disappointed in Cath for letting her anxiety keep her from meeting people and experiencing new things.
As Cath branches out beyond her dorm room, I got more comfortable with the story and started to revel in Cath's quirkyness. Cath is unashamed of her obsession with the wildly popular Simon Snow series. She revels in total lack of desire to party with her sister. And she loves a good hipster sweater. While Cath has a penchant for crying that occasionally made me want to punch her in the face, her quick comebacks and good heart kept me cheering her on.
Then there is sadness. So much sadness.And then there is the ending. But you'll have to read the book to find out if it's happy or not.
Rating: I recommend it, and I'll read it again.
Also Read By: None, but I'll check out more by Rainbow Rowell
Reviewed By: Tami
Tuesday, September 29, 2015
"Exist" by Jennifer Cazey Daniels
I saw an instagram post soliciting bloggers to read an ARC of "Exist." The book would be free in exchange for an honest review. Here are my honest thoughts.
Summary: Ember is a psionic, or a person who is more than human. She has powers that allow her to read minds and feel/broadcast emotions. When her soulmate breaks her heart, she disappears. Although she is no longer visible, the Shadows are able to find her, and Ember must run for her life before they take her over. As she searches New York City for others like her, she comes to terms with her powers and a legacy she didn't know she had.
My Thoughts: I think Daniels has several good ideas throughout Exist. Psychics + love stories + epic battles are a sure-fire recipe for an entertaining book.
However, I feel that Daniels put a lot of plot into her story without truly exploring any of the details for very long. "Exist" almost feels like a summary an entire series instead of a standalone novel. I want to read the story of Ember's past: Ember grew up an orphan, raised by a government agency. What happened to her while she was there? The reader is told that she escaped the agency and I'd love to read about her daring and probably brutal escape. Shortly after her escape she met the love of her life, Aden, and it was a love like no other. Tell me more...was she able to instantly trust him, or was it a long process for her, seeing as she hadn't ever loved or trusted before. (Or had she?)
Ember's life changes after her breakup with Aden. She disappears for goodness sake! I'd like to read more about why this happened---was it just because the breakup left her feeling insignificant or is there something deeper? After the breakup, Ember takes off to hide from the Shadows chasing her. This could be a tale on its own. How does she get to NYC? Does she meet anyone or learn anything on the way? I'd love to see this story end with the epic first showdown with the shadows.
Finally Ember learns about the guild, her past, and the expectations her new society has for her.. This is a great opportunity to go into detail about the different kinds of psionic powers. Let's see them in action. Ember suddenly goes from shy girlie girl to warrior, without much in between. I want to see her transformation!
There is so much unexplored potential in this book - I'd like to read more than what there is.
I'd also like to see Daniels take the time to polish her work. There were some errors that could be fixed that I personally found distracting, and think others would as well: the dialogue formatting was inconsistent, making it hard to tell who was speaking. There were some situations where spell check chose the wrong word (ie her instead of he). And towards the end of the story some of the sentences changed tense in the middle of the line.
Finally, I'm the type of reader that is frustrated by being told instead of shown. I had a hard time connecting to Ember because of this. I felt like she endured crazy, intense, interesting transformations but instead of seeing them unfold, I was just told they happened. The only times I felt like I got to see what the characters were thinking were through massive chunks of monologue that seemed to go on for longer than was needed to get the point across. But then again, I'm older than the target audience so it could only be a matter of taste.
Overall I think this is a decent first attempt at a young adult novel. I like the plot lines and appreciate the creativity and effort that went into the story. It feels like a first draft to me, rather than a second draft or ARC ready copy. I hope Daniels finds a professional editor who can help her break the story down and refine her ideas.
Rating: "Exist" has a Mocking Jay meets New Moon vibe that I think the young adult audience will enjoy once the book has been polished and reworked.
Reviewed By: Tami
Note: Although I received an Advanced Reader Copy of "Exist" for free, all thoughts and opinions are my own.
Summary: Ember is a psionic, or a person who is more than human. She has powers that allow her to read minds and feel/broadcast emotions. When her soulmate breaks her heart, she disappears. Although she is no longer visible, the Shadows are able to find her, and Ember must run for her life before they take her over. As she searches New York City for others like her, she comes to terms with her powers and a legacy she didn't know she had.
My Thoughts: I think Daniels has several good ideas throughout Exist. Psychics + love stories + epic battles are a sure-fire recipe for an entertaining book.
However, I feel that Daniels put a lot of plot into her story without truly exploring any of the details for very long. "Exist" almost feels like a summary an entire series instead of a standalone novel. I want to read the story of Ember's past: Ember grew up an orphan, raised by a government agency. What happened to her while she was there? The reader is told that she escaped the agency and I'd love to read about her daring and probably brutal escape. Shortly after her escape she met the love of her life, Aden, and it was a love like no other. Tell me more...was she able to instantly trust him, or was it a long process for her, seeing as she hadn't ever loved or trusted before. (Or had she?)
Ember's life changes after her breakup with Aden. She disappears for goodness sake! I'd like to read more about why this happened---was it just because the breakup left her feeling insignificant or is there something deeper? After the breakup, Ember takes off to hide from the Shadows chasing her. This could be a tale on its own. How does she get to NYC? Does she meet anyone or learn anything on the way? I'd love to see this story end with the epic first showdown with the shadows.
Finally Ember learns about the guild, her past, and the expectations her new society has for her.. This is a great opportunity to go into detail about the different kinds of psionic powers. Let's see them in action. Ember suddenly goes from shy girlie girl to warrior, without much in between. I want to see her transformation!
There is so much unexplored potential in this book - I'd like to read more than what there is.
I'd also like to see Daniels take the time to polish her work. There were some errors that could be fixed that I personally found distracting, and think others would as well: the dialogue formatting was inconsistent, making it hard to tell who was speaking. There were some situations where spell check chose the wrong word (ie her instead of he). And towards the end of the story some of the sentences changed tense in the middle of the line.
Finally, I'm the type of reader that is frustrated by being told instead of shown. I had a hard time connecting to Ember because of this. I felt like she endured crazy, intense, interesting transformations but instead of seeing them unfold, I was just told they happened. The only times I felt like I got to see what the characters were thinking were through massive chunks of monologue that seemed to go on for longer than was needed to get the point across. But then again, I'm older than the target audience so it could only be a matter of taste.
Overall I think this is a decent first attempt at a young adult novel. I like the plot lines and appreciate the creativity and effort that went into the story. It feels like a first draft to me, rather than a second draft or ARC ready copy. I hope Daniels finds a professional editor who can help her break the story down and refine her ideas.
Rating: "Exist" has a Mocking Jay meets New Moon vibe that I think the young adult audience will enjoy once the book has been polished and reworked.
Reviewed By: Tami
Note: Although I received an Advanced Reader Copy of "Exist" for free, all thoughts and opinions are my own.
Tuesday, April 15, 2014
"Chalice" by Robin McKinley
Robin McKinley writes young adult novels that don't feel like they're aimed at teens. While her characters are smart and witty, they have a maturity about them that is hard to find in contemporary books for the under 18 crowd.
Summary: Bee keeper Marisol is Chalice and therefore is responsible for the well being of her people and demense until a new Master can arrive to set the land and magic back to rights. The new Master will need to rely heavily on Marisol as Chalice so he can attune himself to the land and coach it to respond as it should. There's only one problem...the new Master is a third level fire priest and nobody knows if he is fit to live among humans, much less save the demense from self destruction.
What I Liked:
- Chalice has a clever plot. McKinley has created a whole new world with a rich and well thought out history.
- The characters are excellently developed. Even the most minor character has a back story that adds to the richness of the plot. The main characters are likable, brave yet have enough human vulnerability that the reader can relate to them with ease.
- This is a fresh take on magic. The normal fantasy plot lines are included in the tale, but there are enough twists and unique ideas to keep even the most avid fantasy reader interested.
What Drove Me Nuts:
- The end of the story felt thrown together, almost as if the author had to keep the book under a certain page limit and therefore ended things much too quickly.
- I thought Marisol was uncharacteristically negative towards the end of the story.
- The climax of the story wasn't that climactic. Perhaps I was expecting just a little more.
Rating: This young adult book can hold its own against any mainstream bestseller written for adults. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Also Read By This Author: "Shadows", "Sunshine", "The Hero and the Crown" and "The Blue Sword"
Reviewed By: Tami
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






